When cartoonist, Grace Bennett is given the mandate to take her comic strip from the satirical side of dating to the magical moments between couples in love, she panics. How can she possibly write about something as vital as love when she's never experienced it? What she needs is a miracle. Enter her best friend, Nate Wright, a man with a reputation for falling in love every other weekend. When Nate readily offers to share his extensive knowledge in matters of the heart and give her lessons in love, Gracie has no option but to accept his help.
Nate can't believe his luck. He's been crazy about Gracie since the moment he laid eyes on her, but she's kept him firmly n the friend zone. Helping her out with her comic strip is the perfect opportunity to get closer, show her what real romance is all about and what it could be like with him, but he must keep his ulterior motive on the down low because if she doesn't share his feelings, he risks losing everything.
One kiss has Grace doubting the wisdom in bringing Nate into the mix, while he is more determined than ever to show her that with love, anything is possible.
Business deal behind him, attorney Carter Reed can't wait to get to the airport and put Stone Cliff Resort and the festive town of Deerfield behind him, but impatience, a winter storm and snowy road cause him to accidentally hit a dog, leaving him no choice but to stop and check on it. When a mysterious woman comes to his aid and tells him the injured animal is a magical wolf and he'll soon gain his heart's desire, he's even more determined to get back on the road. He doesn't believe in magic, and the last thing he needs is more false hopes and empty promises.
Biologist, Josie Walker takes one look at Carter and wonders if her Christmas wish has been granted. She'd like nothing more than to take him home and unwrap him, but Scrooge is determined to get out of town.
Carter soon becomes caught up in Josie's spirit of Christmas, but when the storm abates and he's finally able to leave, will he turn his back on the girl who thawed his frozen heart, or find the courage to ask for everything he's always wanted?