After years of feeling abandoned and alone, Father Brian has finally found a home at St. James in sleepy Ashford, Virginia. Brian prepares to take the reins as pastor after his friend and mentor, Father Jacob, preaches his last sermon on a stormy Easter Sunday. Unfortunately, what should be a day of celebration turns into one of uncertainty as Dave and Cindy Simmons, local pillars of their community, along with their three children, are absent from the service. As Brian and Jacob brave the storm to check on the family, Jacob shares the disturbing and gruesome history of the Simmons family history and their connection to a local legend.
The "Bunnyman" is said to have terrorized generations of Ashford residents, but do any of the deranged stories hold truth? As Brian plunges deeper into the mystery, he battles his own demons as his faith is tested around every turn. Can Father Brian reach the Simmons family in time, or will he succumb to the evil that lurks beyond childish whispers.