Elinor Talbot is strong and smart, but she struggles to make ends meet for her family while wrangling her pony farm on weekends. Divorced for years, she isn't looking for romance, however love finds a way when her mischievous kids summon a replacement dad with a Cowboy Spell. With her usual determination, Elinor challenges wickedly handsome, smooth-talking horseshoer Sean Killian to the true test of love.
At almost forty, Sean comes with a painful history, but he knows there's no future in living in the past. He's ready for a family of his own, and he thinks he's finally found the right woman. Honest and hardworking, he calls things as he sees them, putting him and Elinor at loggerheads. Will the magic between them heal their wounded hearts, or is it all an illusion brought about by a Cowboy Spell?