Amish man Levi Fuller faces a crossroads in his relationship with his girlfriend, Lucy. Since his brother's marriage, Lucy's behavior has changed, sparking tension when she criticizes Levi's new sister-in-law. Their relationship is further strained by the influence of Lucy's friend, who has just returned from rumspringa and advises Lucy against Levi. Amidst this, Levi wonders if his mother's disapproval of Lucy is a sign he's been overlooking. As Levi grapples with these challenges, he must decide whether to resolve things with Lucy or consider the attention of another who shows interest in him.