What would you do if you could live your life over again? Retired teacher Stanley Huckle wonders whether his life would have been different if he'd been a bolder, braver man. He's always put duty first: to his aged parents, to his students, to his community. What if he'd put himself first? One cold night when his furnace breaks down, a mysterious repairman appears, offering Stanley his second chance at life. If he takes it, he gets the road not taken. If he refuses, he loses what he thinks is his one chance at lost happiness. What would you do?