"It Was All A Joke" is an emotional tale of Sarah and David, a couple seeking to infuse excitement into their relationship by pretending to be strangers named Alex and Lily. Their innocent game takes an unexpected turn as they become deeply entwined in their fabricated identities. However, when David finally reveals his true self, admitting to the charade, trust is shattered and their bond faces a severe test. Despite his efforts to mend the relationship, Sarah's pain runs deep. It takes a stormy night, heartfelt letters, and time for her to realize her enduring love for David. The story explores themes of trust, forgiveness, and the resilience of love, as the couple works through their issues and emerges stronger than before.