Emma has been in love with Jacob for quite a long time now. She has dreamed of the day when he finally realizes that he loves her too, and when he asks to walk her home and speak with her privately about an important matter, she believes that her time has come.
When she believes that Jacob chickened out from a proposal, she decides to tell him how she feels herself. But on the way to see him, she runs into Daniel, the other town heartthrob. What he has to tell her shocks her, but she cannot allow him to alter her decision.
When all of her plans fall apart, will she make the decision that is easy, or will she make the plan that she knows is the right one for herself? All she knows is that neither Daniel nor Jacob will make it easy for her.