Mindy is still scarred by her time at high school, so when she gets an invitation to a reunion it brings back the painful memories, and all she wants to do is crumple it up and throw it away. However, her husband urges her to go, but while there she meets the man who used to be the boy she was in love with, and the girl that remained inside her still wants her dreams to come true, even though it could be to the detriment of her marriage, and the temptation to re-write the past is too great.