Jonah Gentry knows his family is a lot, so, it's been three years since he visited them back in Atlanta. As hesitant as he might be to spend another holiday with them, Jonah finds his reluctance is quickly assuaged when he meets the gorgeous man sitting next to him on the plane. After an amazing night together, Jonah realizes he isn't sure he's up for competing with the other man who has a place in this man's heart, Jesus.
Paul Carrington left Alabama years ago. Twenty years later, he's built a life for himself with a thriving business, and a nice house he's hoping to fill with just the right guy. When he meets a man on a plane ride back from Portland, he wonders if maybe Jonah might be the one. Then Jonah leaves him standing in his bathrobe in the middle of the street chasing after his cab.
When Paul and Jonah find themselves next to each other at Jonah's mother's Christmas dinner, sparks fly. Can Jonah work through his family and religious issues enough to work it out with the guy with the kind eyes? Can Paul forgive the man who left him without saying goodbye? Or is it just another holiday down the tubes?